Art & Life: A Reflection on Expectations of Chris Brown and Rihanna

Cyrillic lookin fonts never get old, no matter how many times you use them on Roman letters. Both Rihanna and Chris Brown are back. As Slate pointed out, there is something very cringe-worthy about enjoying Brown’s work. One of his new singles, “I Can Transform Ya,” is cocky and self-assured, and, content-wise, totally unrelated to his recent plea of guilt in the state of California. The single features Lil Wayne, who, besides fraternizing with a domestic abuser, has his own problems these days.

Anyway, even if it is absolutely morally revolting to enjoy Chris Brown (I know it is for me), I would never suggest we ban his music from our personal listening rotation. Even though his artistic persona has been revealed as a total lie, (as Slate noted, “An R&B loverman best known for a domestic-violence conviction is an insupportable contradiction”), art still needs distance from the personal life of the artist. We’d have pretty much no one to appreciate if all artists were judged by the merits of their personal character or politics–that’s right, we’d have to say good-bye to Polanski, Woody Allen, Heidegger, etc. I’m just trying to say that I hate censorship, and only believe it’s necessary when hate speech enters the ring.

Rihanna’s new single, unlike Brown’s, doesn’t enjoy very much liberty from the February assault. Its first sound is the cry of a lone guitar streaming across the sonic landscape, signaling a Red Dawn. “Russian Roulette” isn’t about Russia, however–though the cyrillic-lookin font plastering the single cover might have you thinking differently (see above). The song’s mood is foreboding, the lyrics dark, the song structure torn out of the heartbroken-ballad song book.  The last sound in the song is a gun shot, because, ahem, she lost at the high stakes game of roulette.

I think it’s unfair to only read this song through the lens of her recent life events, but I’m doing it to illustrate a point. It’s more acceptable in this here society to let the abusers move on, artistically unscathed, while Rihanna, the abused, returns with a persona that recalls this year’s events.

Yet, detractors may say, Rihanna’s always had a dark side. Even the sundrenched Barbados days of her earlier singles were tinged with the chaos-making agents of love, that is, madness and desperation. (See: S.O.S.) Detractors, I agree. But check out this further evidence that Rihanna’s new stuff is related to her personal life:

In this month’s issue of Glamour, Rihanna says of her new album:

I put everything I’ve wanted to say for the past eight months into my music. The songs are really personal.

So that’s good, if it helped her deal. I’m not asking Rihanna to do anything contrary to what she feels like doing. But we women are always supposed to infuse our art with emotion and personal experience. When women’s art is detached from our emotional life, we’re accused of being cold and fucked up. No one expects any kind of musical reflection from Chris Brown. He is free to be whoever the fuck he wants to be, and no one will ever wonder why he didn’t make a song about what it feels like to be a domestic abuser.

One day, I hope women won’t be chained (or barb-wired, as is the case with Rihanna) to our feelings. In the meantime, I still can’t wait for November 23rd, the day Rihanna’s cd comes out.


2 thoughts on “Art & Life: A Reflection on Expectations of Chris Brown and Rihanna

  1. Women can be so annoying reading so deep into stuff and creating 1000 meanings and points out of every little thing. Rhianna is trying to sell CD’s lets just be real. I can’t stand to hear celebs say they want their privacy and bla bla, then they come out into the public and run their mouth. Thats one reason I like Tyra Banks. CB is trying to sell cd’s as well however he isn’t using the situation to do so, basically cause that want work, he isnt the victim. But before all this I think in my opinion CB put out better material that Rhianna and from what I’ve heard of their new stuff, he still is. Thats all that should matter @ the end of the day, who’s music do you prefer? All this personal shit is for the dogs.

  2. I will take it as a compliment that we women read so deep into stuff… without this ability, there would be no criticism. Apparently the fairer sex fares better at this pursuit.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s